The
Trouble with Instituting PLCs
I sat through the keynote speeches, excited by the
prospect of finally bringing true Professional
Learning Communities (PLCs) to my school. Having witnessed well-functioning
teams around the state, I knew that this could be a powerful process for
supporting student success. I had studied the PLC process in one of my classes
at the University, and felt like I was going in with enthusiasm, but at the
same time, with both eyes open. In another of my university courses we had read
articles on the watering-down of PLCs, and pseudo-PLCs (most often in the
secondary setting), which in the end rendered the term PLC practically
meaningless. I was determined that with my help this would not be the case for
this school.
At the end of the second day, my enthusiasm had begun
to wane. Sadly, some of the sessions were disappointing – great content with
dull presenters versus charismatic presenters with not much content. Following
that, we were asked to meet with our teams to work on our implementation
strategies. Everyone talking at once, bits and pieces of information flying
around the table: a complete lack of organization. The third day was a half
day, so the principal asked everyone to stay and work for a couple of hours
again at that time.
Unfortunately, or maybe fortunately, that was the
night I fell ill. The thought of two more aimless hours of disorganized
brainstorming was more than I could bear. This is a frustration I feel in this
“Twilight Zone” of being not quite a teacher, but not actually being an
administrator. As a part of the administrative team, I would have had the clout
to say “Hey, let’s not put the cart before the horse, and let’s start at the
beginning before it all gets jumbled up and becomes one more great idea we
tried and couldn’t hold on to.”
I’ve been afraid to ask how that meeting went, and no
one has volunteered to share. Educators are an enthusiastic bunch in general,
but often rush in without a plan, and not taking the time to realize that true
change does not occur overnight, and normally not without some pain and
sacrifice along the way. I think it’s time for me to gird my loins and find out
where the process stands. I hope to yet be a voice of reason, and to share my
ideas initially with the principal and maybe one or two others, with the dream
of keeping the process on track so that the school will truly be a Professional
Learning Community in every sense of the word.